Dark Matter Season 2 Episode 3 "Everything Beautiful, Everything Terrible" Recap: The Box Cannot Be Destroyed

Dark Matter continues to expand its multiverse in Season 2, but this episode makes one thing increasingly clear, that the real danger is no longer simply getting lost between worlds, because the technology Jason and the others have discovered is beginning to change how entire realities interact with one another.

The episode jumps between Jason and his family trying to build a normal life, Leighton turning the Box into the foundation of a multiversal business, and Amanda and Ryan attempting to find their way home, while the consequences of Season 1 continue catching up with everyone. Most importantly, Jason believes he has found a way to destroy the Box and protect his family, only to discover that the multiverse may not allow him to close the door that easily!

The Box Was Always Going to Create Something Beautiful and Terrible

The episode opens with a flashback from three years earlier, when Jason 2 is still discussing the theoretical possibilities of superposition with his former professors. Jason presents the Box as a hypothetical invention and asks what happens when humanity creates technology capable of accessing entirely different realities, but one of his professors quickly turns the question into something much bigger than the science itself. He compares the Box to major inventions such as sailing ships and the internet, arguing that once humanity discovers something capable of changing the world, it will inevitably produce both incredible benefits and devastating consequences, which is why the Box will ultimately bring about "everything beautiful and everything terrible."

The professor also dismisses the idea that humanity can decide whether it should build something like this, because if the technology can be created, someone eventually will create it. I really like this scene because it gives the multiverse storyline a philosophical foundation instead of treating the Box as nothing more than a cool science-fiction device. That idea becomes especially important later in the episode, because the characters are beginning to discover that the Box cannot simply be treated like a door that can be locked from one side or destroyed.

Jason Tries to Build a New Life While Secretly Studying the Box

The Dessens are still attempting to settle into their new life in a low-tech world, and the small details show how badly they want some sense of normality after everything they have experienced. They decorate their Christmas tree with an ornament resembling the one from their original world, while Charlie starts school, gets a skateboard and begins making mixtapes, giving the family pieces of an ordinary teenage life that they were never able to have while running from alternate versions of Jason. The family also takes precautions against another variant infiltrating their lives by creating matching tattoos, with Charlie helping design them, as a secret safe sign that only the "real" family members should have. The decision to use a tattoo as a way to identify each other comes after Jason struggles to remember the safe word when he is tested, throwing out Van Gogh and Vermeer before finally remembering Degas, which is funny on the surface but also shows just how much pressure the Dessens is under. Unfortunately, Jason is not nearly as ready to leave the Box behind as he tells Daniela. He claims that he is mixing explosives using saltpeter so he can destroy the technology, but he is actually dismantling the Box piece by piece and taking detailed notes because he still wants to understand how it works. Jason's obsession with the science is beginning to resemble the very mindset that caused so many problems in the first place, and there is a point where his desire to understand the Box starts looking dangerously similar to Jason 2's obsession with controlling it.

Daniela eventually discovers what he has been doing at the abandoned school, and she immediately realizes that Jason has lied to her. She is particularly angry because he has been spending time secretly working on the Box while missing Charlie's prom send-off, forcing Jason to finally rip out the Box and prove to her that he is willing to let the technology go.

Join the Spiral

Join 2,000+ Sci-Fi Fans and Get daily SciFi news, reviews, and updates straight to your inbox

Subscribe

We respect your privacy. Read our privacy policy. Unsubscribe anytime.

Daniela Runs into Blair Again

Daniela's attempt to move forward takes an unexpected turn when she runs into Blair at the DMV. Blair explains that she returned about six months earlier after spending years living as a nomad, and the conversation quickly becomes more complicated because Daniela is using the name "Daniela Stewart" to keep her real identity hidden. There is an interesting tension between them as they talk about the lives they used to have, because both women seem to recognize pieces of their shared history without fully understanding what has happened to the other.

The scene is deliberately quiet compared with the episode's action sequences, but that makes the uncertainty around Blair even more interesting. There is already speculation that this could actually be Blair 2 from Jason 2's reality, and I can understand why viewers are reading the scene that way, especially because Blair seems to notice details about Daniela's story that do not quite add up. If the show is setting up another variant reveal here, it is taking a much more subtle approach than the Jason storyline, which could make the eventual payoff even more effective.

Leighton Is Turning the Multiverse into a Business

While Jason is trying to destroy the Box, Leighton Vance is doing almost the exact opposite by using the technology to build a multiversal trading network. Leighton travels between realities and uses Velocity Pharmaceuticals to provide vaccines and medical treatment to a world devastated by a severe pandemic, while also visiting his grandfather Ezekiel Vance in the hospital. On the surface, this makes Leighton's operation look almost heroic because he is using technology from one reality to solve problems in another, but the larger implications are much harder to ignore.

In another low-tech version of Chicago, Detective MacNamara is hired by his sister Sheila to investigate how Leighton's Velocity-Tech managed to beat their family business to market with advanced microprocessors. That means Leighton's multiversal activities are already producing economic consequences in worlds that have no idea where the technology is coming from.

The pandemic storyline is particularly concerning because moving medicine between realities also means moving biological material between realities, and the possibility of accidentally introducing a pathogen into another world is exactly the kind of consequence Jason's professor warned about in the opening scene. Leighton may believe he is building something useful, but the scale of what he is doing makes his operation potentially much more dangerous than anything a normal technology company could create.

Amanda and Ryan Finally Make It Back to Chicago

Amanda and Ryan discover another important trick for navigating the Box when they stop focusing on the characteristics of the world they want to reach and instead concentrate on persons related to the world that they want.

That allows them to navigate back to Ryan's original universe, where they find the Box encased in concrete and finally return to Chicago. Their reunion with Jason 2 immediately becomes complicated when they enter Ryan's apartment and discover another Ryan Holder living there. This second Ryan is a mechanic variant who was brought into this reality by Jason 2 (Season 1). The original Ryan is understandably furious when Jason 2 arrives and punches him directly in the jaw, giving us a satisfying moment after everything Jason 2 put him through. Unfortunately, there is barely any time to deal with the situation because DARPA agents and Detective MacNamara soon surround the building. DARPA has been tracking the aftermath of the duplicate Jasons who flooded Chicago in Season 1, and Ryan and Amanda suddenly find themselves caught in the middle of an investigation that has been building since the previous season. Jason 13 opens fire through the window to give them a chance to escape, and the sequence turns into a frantic car chase that feels almost like something from a Jason Bourne movie before they manage to get back into the Box.

The Box Comes Back

Jason believes he has finally solved the problem after dismantling the Box, but the episode saves its biggest twist for the final minutes. After telling Daniela that the Box is gone, Jason returns to the abandoned pool one final time to get rid of the remaining components. Instead, he discovers something that completely changes his understanding of the technology. A brand-new Box has appeared in exactly the same location.

Jason realizes that destroying the physical structure does not actually disconnect a world from the Corridor, because if another person enters superposition and connects to that reality, the Box can materialize again. That revelation completely destroys the idea that Jason can protect his family by destroying the machine in their world. The Box is no longer just an object sitting somewhere that can be dismantled, buried or blown up, because its existence is connected to something much larger than the physical structure itself.

Jason immediately races home and tests Daniela and Charlie using their secret safe tattoo because the appearance of the new Box raises the terrifying possibility that one of them could already have been replaced by a variant. The ending is genuinely unsettling because Jason has spent the entire episode trying to remove the multiverse from his family's life, only to discover that the multiverse can simply come back.

That is what makes the episode's opening conversation so important in hindsight: the Box really has brought both the beautiful and the terrible, and there may be no way for Jason to decide which one reaches his family next.

This episode works particularly well because it expands Dark Matter beyond Jason's personal search for a safe reality and starts exploring what happens when multiversal travel becomes something other people can actually use.

I also like that the episode does not treat Jason's scientific curiosity as completely harmless, because his decision to secretly study the Box while telling Daniela he intends to destroy it shows that he still has some of the same instincts that made his situation so dangerous before but the Box returning is the real game changer. Jason thought destroying the Box would give his family a way out of the multiverse, and instead he learns that the door can simply appear again whenever someone else finds their way through. At this point, the biggest threat is no longer whether Jason can find his way home but whether there is such a thing as home anymore.