Amazon's Stargate Reboot: Why Fans Are Worried

On June the second this year, Amazon canceled Stargate, arguing that the script would only appeal to existing Stargate fans rather than attracting the wider audience Amazon is trying to reach.

Four months later, Amazon finally gave the project the green light. But instead of celebrating, fans grew even angrier. The reason? Amazon had completely sidelined the original creative team behind the established Stargate canon and replaced them with an outside team that, in the eyes of many fans, has little experience handling a universe like Stargate.

Changing the Old Guard

Amazon initially gave the greenlight to Martin Gero, a longtime Stargate writer. Gero mapped out the entire first season and put together a casting list, which presumably included some familiar faces from the original shows.

Then, out of nowhere, Amazon executives pulled the plug. Their reasoning is that the project would only appeal to existing Stargate fans and wouldn't attract Gen Z or bring in a new audience.

The cancellation hit the fandom hard. Fans felt insulted, as if their loyalty to the franchise wasn't enough to justify continuing the story they loved. That's when the #SaveStargate campaign took off, collecting more than 100,000 signatures, with original cast members and writers joining the fight. Thousands of posts have flooded social media every day for months. Fans have held rallies in Times Square, and things even went as far as renting a plane to fly over Amazon Studios with a #SaveStargate banner to make their message impossible to ignore.

On October 9, Amazon finally responded by bringing the project back. But there was a catch: Gero's version was being replaced by a new creative team led by Jac Schaeffer.

Instead of celebrating the news, the fandom reacted with concern. The big question was whether the original vision would survive or whether the new team would change the canon and rewrite the very things that made Stargate special to begin with.

Who Is Jac Schaeffer and How Will She Affect Stargate?

Jac Schaeffer is an American writer, director, and screenwriter best known for her work on Marvel's WandaVision and Agatha All Along. She's certainly not a bad writer, but the tone and vibe of Stargate are completely new territory for her, and that's what worries us all.

Her writing tends to lean toward grief-driven narratives, highly stylized world-building, and grounded, character-focused storytelling. Those elements could clash with what makes Stargate unique: its military sci-fi roots, campy humor, and expansive universe.

So, there's little doubt that the franchise's flavor will change. The real question is whether that change will be for better or worse. As I mentioned earlier, this is unfamiliar territory for Schaeffer, which makes it nearly impossible to predict how she'll handle the franchise with any real confidence. Anyone claiming to know how this will turn out is getting ahead of themselves.

Amazon has also emphasized that the reboot should be accessible to newcomers, not just hardcore fans who have followed the franchise for years. That doesn't necessarily mean it'll be a hard reboot, though.

Join the Spiral

Join 2,000+ Sci-Fi Fans and Get daily SciFi news, reviews, and updates straight to your inbox

We respect your privacy. Read our privacy policy. Unsubscribe anytime.

Where the Problem Lies

What scares Stargate fans is that all this history and lore, built over 350 episodes from SG-1 to Universe, apparently wasn't enough to convince Amazon that the franchise could attract a new audience. If that tells us anything, it's that some major changes are coming. Or, as I put it in one of my posts on X, they're going to change Stargate's DNA.

And that's what scares us as fans of this universe, because to us, the lore is sacred. It's crazy, how can you look at 20 years of established canon and see it as an obstacle to attracting new viewers?!